The Trust-Building Process in Therapy, Explained
You sat down for your first session expecting to feel something like relief. instead you felt... careful. measured. like you were testing the water before you put your whole foot in.
If that's been your experience, i want you to know something clearly: that's not you doing therapy wrong. that's what the beginning is supposed to feel like.
how long does it take to trust a therapist?
there's no universal timeline. it depends on you, your history, and the fit with your therapist. but if you're a few sessions in and still feel guarded, that's not a sign something's wrong. it's actually one of the most normal parts of starting therapy.
trust isn't a given: it's built
a therapist doesn't expect you to hand over your whole story on day one. and honestly, you shouldn't want to. trust is something that gets built session by session, as your therapist gets to know the specific ways you move through the world — not just the general shape of "someone with your history," but you, specifically.
that attunement takes time. it takes your therapist paying attention to what lands and what doesn't. and it takes you being willing to tell them.
therapy feels awkward at first: is that normal?
if you're a high achiever, like many of my clients, you're probably used to being the one who has it figured out. you read the room, you adapt, you perform well under new circumstances. therapy asks you to do the opposite; to sit in not knowing, to let someone else lead for a minute, to be witnessed before you're ready to be witnessed.
that discomfort isn't a red flag. it's the process working. but it's still uncomfortable, and it deserves to be named instead of pushed through silently.
Your voice matters here. More than you think.
if you've caught yourself thinking "why don't i trust my therapist yet" the answer is often simpler than it feels. trust isn't just something a therapist earns passively. it's something you build together, and learning how to advocate for yourself in therapy is a huge part of that.
here's the part that often gets missed: you are not a passive participant in this. your therapist is attuning to you, yes but they can only do that with information you give them.
that means:
if something a therapist says doesn't land right, you're allowed to say so
if a technique feels wrong for how your brain works, you're allowed to ask for something different
if you're not sure why you're doing a particular exercise, you're allowed to ask
if a session leaves you feeling worse and not in a "good hard work" way, that's worth naming out loud
this isn't you being difficult. this is you doing your part in a relationship that only works when both people are honest.
how to tell your therapist something isn't working (and ask for a different approach)
start simple. you might say something like:
"i don't think this approach is landing for me — can we try something different?"
"i felt kind of shut down after our last session and i'm not sure why."
"i think i need more structure than we've been doing."
most therapists won't be defensive about this. they'll get curious with you. adjusting course isn't a failure on their part — it's literally the job.
and if they don't listen?
this is the part i want to say plainly: if you bring this up more than once, clearly, and your therapist keeps doing the same thing anyway that tells you something important. you're allowed to honor that. you're allowed to name it directly. and you're allowed to leave.
the right fit is not you shrinking your needs to make the relationship work. it's a therapist who can hold your needs and adjust to meet them.
the takeaway
building safety in therapy isn't a straight line, and it isn't instant. it's built through small, honest moments. you naming what's true for you, and your therapist actually listening. that back-and-forth is the relationship. and it's worth protecting.
Learn more about what sessions are like with me!
Contact me today to learn more!
